close
close

Los Angeles: That’s why the fire destroys houses, but not trees

Los Angeles: That’s why the fire destroys houses, but not trees

Published

Fact checkHouses burn down, trees don’t: How is that supposed to work?

Apocalyptic scenes in Los Angeles: fires blazing, smoke lies over the city. Thousands of houses burned down. Unlike many trees. This causes conspiracy theories.

Fee Anabelle Riebeling
from

“What kind of investors have plans here?” “Warm demolition?” With these words, many social media users comment on images of the damage caused by the catastrophic fires in Los Angeles – especially those that show houses burned to the ground, while the trees next to them appear to be unscathed are remainers.

The claim

According to users, the recordings suggest that the forest fires might not be doing the right things. A claim that has already appeared in previous forest fires: for example in the devastating forest fires in Canada in 2023. At that time speculatedthe fires were caused by energy weapons. Just like after the forest fires in Hawaii that same year. At that time some people said: “Something’s wrong here.”

The review

The claims are false. There are various reasons why houses and trees survive fires differently. “There is a physical explanation why trunks and large branches of trees don’t burn, but houses do,” Ernesto Alvarado of the University of Washington’s Department of Environmental and Forestry Sciences told the news agency after the Hawaii wildfires AFP.

Vegetation is also affected by the fire

First of all: In California, not only buildings burned and burned, but also vegetation. There is plenty of visual evidence of this – both in the media and on social media. Trees, bushes and hedges have also fallen victim to the flames in the last few days.

Type of trees plays a role

How well the plants resist the flames depends on their art. Tropical trees, for example, often had a very high water content. This means “even in dry conditions they burn less easily than grass and all the dry wooden houses and buildings from which they are built,” Camille Stevens-Rumann of the Colorado Forest Restoration Institute told AFP.

Trees have learned to adapt

According to the Americans National Forest Foundation and the non-profit organization American forests Some trees – especially in the western United States – have adapted to the conditions as a result of the recurring forest fires: They have developed thicker bark. This doesn’t catch fire so quickly. “It also protects the interior of the trunk, the living tissue that transports water and nutrients, from heat damage.” It takes an enormous amount of heat over a long period of time to burn directly through a trunk, according to US biologist David Peterson -Ministry of Agriculture Scientificalert.com.

Ponderosa pines are masters of adaptation

A particularly good example of the adaptability of trees is the ponderosa pine (Pinus ponderosa): its bark is not only thick, but also scaly. This helps it withstand surface fires. It also loses its lower branches as it gets older. This prevents the fire from climbing upwards and burning the green needles further up the tree. The treetops remained moist, only the trunks scorched, Jennifer Marlon of the Yale School of Forestry and Environmental Studies admitted in 2020 Verifythis.com. But larches, oaks and firs had also adapted over time.

Trees offer less of a target for sparks than houses

Fires produce glowing sparks that fall onto roofs, patios or other flammable surfaces and start new fires. Homes with dry materials are more susceptible to this. Houses offer “many nooks and crannies from the roof to the foundation where wind-borne embers – burning pieces of wood and plants – can land and ignite,” Courtney Peterson, a climate adaptation specialist at Colorado State University, told AFP. These could fly for kilometers. However, trees had fewer flat surfaces for sparks to land and burn.

Rain of fire: Embers flew through the air in the community of Pacific Palisades on January 8, 2025.

Rain of fire: Embers flew through the air in the community of Pacific Palisades on January 8, 2025.

Getty Images

Materials in materials, on and around buildings also play a role

Many of the homes that have now fallen victim to the fire in California are made of wood that was dry, unlike the trees around them. In addition, buildings often contain highly flammable materials such as wood, plastic, insulation and roofing felt.

“With American construction, a spark is often enough for houses,” says fire ecologist Johann Georg Goldammer from the Global Fire Monitoring Center in Freiburg (D). Bild.de. “The houses are often sealed off with plastic. It burns quickly.” There are also numerous combustible materials inside.

“With American construction, a spark is often enough for houses.”

Johann Georg Goldammer from the Global Fire Monitoring Center in Freiburg (D)

In addition, oxygen can enter the house through windows, doors and cracks, which further fuels the fire. What’s more, “Man-made structures have lots of little holes through which embers can fly or be sucked into the house, and then it’s all over,” says Marlon.

Flying sparks: Every weak point serves as a breeding ground for the raining embers.

Flying sparks: Every weak point serves as a breeding ground for the raining embers.

Anadolu via Getty Images

The surroundings of houses should be tidy

According to the Americans NFPA (National Fire Protection Association), the design of the area around houses also plays a crucial role. These include the distance from trees, the placement of combustible materials such as stacks of firewood, but also the cleanliness of gutters. If there are leaves or pine needles in there, they are a target for falling embers. But the length of the lawn also plays a role. It should not be higher than ten centimeters.

A zone of up to 200 feet (around 60 meters) is relevant for fire protection. However, due to the dense construction, this is not always possible. The area up to nine meters is considered the highest.

The graphic from the National Fire Protection Association shows how large the so-called “Home Ignition Zone” is.

The graphic from the National Fire Protection Association shows how large the so-called “Home Ignition Zone” is.

NFPA

A look at Hawaii shows what a difference paying attention to such factors can make: While the 2023 forest fires in Lāhainā razed many houses to the ground, some houses survived the devastating fire largely unscathed. For example this one:

However, keeping the areas around the house clear is not a guarantee. “When it comes to natural disasters, there are no guarantees,” Npr.org quotes Faraz Hedayati of the Insurance Institute for Business & Home Safety, which surveyed surviving buildings after the Lahaina wildfires.

Conclusion

Contrary to what one social media user suggested, it is not uncommon for homes to be destroyed in the fierce wildfires in California while many trees are still standing. There are several physical reasons why buildings and trees survive fire differently. For example, houses offer a larger attack surface due to their construction, their building materials, the building density in the region and the design of the surrounding area. The adaptability of the trees in the region also plays a role.

Don’t fall back on fake news! Subscribe to Fact Check channel notifications in the 20 Minutes app. This will help you stay up to date on the veracity of claims from the wide world of social media. Is the latest news about the coronavirus correct, do you really see Australian soldiers in the viral video and have UFOs actually landed on Earth?

Here’s how to do it: Install the latest version of the 20-minute app. Tap the Settings menu (three lines with a circle) in the top right, then tap Settings, then tap Push Notifications. Select the topics you want and then click Next. Now select a region if desired and click “Next”. Under “Topics” you can now select “Fact Check”. Click “Confirm” and you’re in!

Have you been following on Whatsapp for 20 minutes?

A news overview in the morning and at the end of the day, surprising stories and breaking news: Subscribe to the 20 Minutes WhatsApp channel and you will receive regular updates with our best stories directly to your cell phone.